Skip to main content

Jersey City Fish House Punch

This is one of our End of Prohibition party special punch recipes and it was adapted from the Philadelphia Fish House punch, which was a favorite of Generals Washington and Lafayette. We replaced the original cognac with our local Laird’s AppleJack and got something fantastic as a result. We use all seasonal fruits for this—a beautiful feature that also makes it extra tasty.

Recipe information

  • Yield

    makes 5 3/4 quarts

Ingredients

Decorative ice block (opposite page)
6 Fuji apples, diced
6 large Bartlett pears, diced
6 lemons, cut into half-wheels
6 limes, cut into half-wheels
3 cups Smith & Cross Traditional Jamaica rum
1 quart Laird’s AppleJack
1 quart freshly squeezed lemon juice
2 quarts water
3/4 cup Massenez crème de pêche or peach liqueur

Preparation

  1. Step 1

    Prepare the decorative ice block, allowing a few hours for freezing.

    Step 2

    Combine the fruits in a large punch bowl and add the rum, AppleJack, juice, water, and liqueur. Refrigerate for at least 4 to 5 hours. Just before serving, add the decorative ice block.

Cover of Speakeasy by Jason Kosmas and Dushan Zaric featuring a coupe glass with a brown cocktail and lemon wheel garnish.
Reprinted with permission from Speakeasy: The Employees Only Guide to Classic Cocktails Reimagined by Jason Kosmas and Dushan Zaric, © 2010 Ten Speed Press. Buy the full book from Amazon or Bookshop.
Read More
Like “absolutely decadent” chocolate pudding and fattoush salad.
Keep this easy frittata recipe on hand for quick breakfasts, impressive brunches, and fridge clean-out meals.
Turn humble onions into this thrifty yet luxe pasta dinner.
A warmly spiced Ashkenazi charoset, perfect for your Passover seder—or spooned over yogurt the next morning.
A flurry of fresh tarragon makes this speedy weeknight dish of seared cod and luscious, sun-colored pan sauce feel restaurant worthy.
Like lemony risotto and tandoori-style cauliflower.
Grab your Easter basket and hop in—you’ll want to collect each and every one of these fun and easy Easter recipes.
For Derby Day indulgence or a post-Thanksgiving lunch, this Kentucky favorite can’t be beat.